
Community and private foundations should select salary benchmarking peers by actual job responsibilities, grantmaking model, organizational complexity, geography and the market from which they recruit. Similar assets or proximity alone do not establish comparability. A defensible peer set is one that a compensation committee can explain, including why particular organizations and roles were included or excluded.
Foundation executives and HR teams often confront two difficult cases: their foundation's titles do not match survey titles, or a highly specialized job competes with employers outside philanthropy. Both call for more than downloading one sector average. This guide focuses on how to choose foundation salary benchmarking peers. For organization-wide study design, see the separate compensation study process.
For US foundation boards, HR directors, finance teams and compensation committees. Reviewed November 18, 2026. Examples below illustrate methods rather than real employer outcomes.
Key Takeaways
- Match the work before the organization: responsibility, job level and decision authority are the initial screens.
- Segment foundation types: community, private, family and operating foundations can have different talent markets.
- Keep peer groups traceable: distinguish direct grantmaker comparators from adjacent nonprofit and broader labor-market evidence.
- Inspect survey quality: determine the data year, job-match strength, sample sufficiency and pay components.
- Explain uncertainty: do not disguise sparse samples or sensitivity to geography as precision.
What Does a Comparable Foundation Really Mean?
A useful peer is an employer whose compensation observation is relevant to the same work under sufficiently similar conditions. The peer should help answer a practical hiring or retention question, not simply make a board presentation look well supported. Organizational reputation, charitable designation and headline asset size are imperfect substitutes for the responsibilities of the job being evaluated.
For example, a community foundation's director of donor services may manage donor-advised fund relationships, regional charitable partnerships and complex transaction workflows. A private foundation's program director may oversee a specialist grant portfolio and policy research without an equivalent donor-facing role. These organizations might remain suitable peers for some finance jobs while being poor matches for one another's program or donor-services posts.
The Council on Foundations' 2026 Grantmaker Salary and Benefits Report offers grantmaker-sector data organized by grantmaker or foundation type, asset size and geography. This is useful context, but researchers still need to read position definitions. The market survey data quality guide describes how to test sample relevance before applying a reported market value.
Evaluate Every Candidate Peer Across Five Dimensions
| Peer dimension | What to compare | Illustrative mismatch to investigate |
|---|---|---|
| Role substance | Decision rights, grants or budgets managed, team size, technical skill, reporting line and leadership responsibility | The same title covers portfolio strategy at one foundation and transactional administration at another |
| Grantmaker type | Community, private, family, corporate or operating model; donor services; types of grants or programs | A donor-services leadership role is compared with a grantmaker that has no donor-facing operation |
| Scale and complexity | Asset portfolio, grant volume, annual operations, staff model, outsourced functions and governance exposure | Similar endowments mask major differences in staff size, staffing model or portfolio responsibilities |
| Recruiting market | Local or national hiring, remote work expectations and competing employers for scarce talent | A nationally recruited investment professional is compared only with local generalists |
| Data quality | Survey job description, collection date, pay definition, sample size, exclusions and data-license terms | The market median relies on a sparse or outdated group with incomplete total compensation |
No universal formula requires all five dimensions to carry equal weight. A job-by-job assessment is more defensible than using one arbitrary organization-level peer list. For a position requiring rare grants management software skills, labor-market competition may deserve greater attention. For an executive managing philanthropic strategy and board relationships, governance scope and decision rights may be more material.
A documented framework helps prevent the temptation to keep only high-paying organizations in the final sample. The broader executive compensation peer-group guide addresses this principle across sectors; foundations should apply it through their own grantmaking and role definitions.
Should Community and Private Foundations Have Different Peer Groups?
Often yes, depending on the job. Community foundations commonly need donor engagement, community partnerships, grant administration and local philanthropic relationship capacity. Private foundations may recruit for different combinations of grants strategy, philanthropy research, family-office interfaces, investment operations and executive support. Neither category is homogeneous, so labels should guide screening rather than dictate the final list.
For common functions such as payroll, financial reporting or HR operations, adjacent nonprofits and private employers may provide valid supporting observations if the job scope truly matches. For grantmaking roles, sector specialization can materially affect job matching. The nonprofit compensation data-source comparison is a useful companion to evaluating survey coverage, while the general nonprofit salary benchmarking guide covers broader pay-range design.
The Council's 2026 survey guidance references 38 position titles and acknowledges variations in individual foundations' titles. A title label is therefore a search aid, not a substitute for reading a position description.
Use Three Evidence Tiers Without Blending Them Blindly
Organize your evidence in layers. Tier 1 is closely matched foundations with the strongest role and scale alignment. Tier 2 is other grantmakers or mission-based employers with transferable work. Tier 3 is a broader recruitment market, such as regional employers hiring a specialized finance, technology or investment leader. The tiers are an analytical convenience, not a federal standard.
Report the tiers separately before forming a recommendation. If a national specialist market suggests a different pay range from local grantmaker peers, explain why one is more predictive for the actual vacancy. Ask what changes when the benchmark excludes unusual organizations or when a limited-sample market estimate is treated as low-confidence evidence.
Foundation HR leaders should also distinguish base salary, annual cash incentives, deferred compensation, employer contributions and the full remuneration package. A CEO comparison on base salary alone can miss important differences in value. See the nonprofit CEO compensation guide for the wider executive-pay context.
How to Choose and Validate Survey Sources
Start with surveys that describe their job definitions and population. Ask the provider whether data can be filtered by grantmaker type, assets, staff size or location, and whether small samples are suppressed. Check survey effective dates rather than confusing report publication with the period represented by pay observations. The 2026 Council on Foundations report can inform the sector screen; the custom salary survey service may be appropriate when the published survey misses a critical role.
Public IRS Form 990 and Form 990-PF filings can provide background about organizations and certain disclosed compensation. They are not inherently current job-matched market surveys, and public filings often provide insufficient functional detail to compare roles confidently. Do not use a Form 990 executive figure as though it were a complete survey percentile.
For a formal project request, state whether the consultant must obtain licensed survey access, what data rights the foundation will retain and how weak job matches will be flagged. The compensation study budget and RFP guide helps translate those specifications into procurement questions.
How Should Boards Document Peer Selection?
The board packet should identify the decision, covered positions, job descriptions, the peer list and screening reasons, data vintages and compensation definitions, limitations, and conclusions. Show at least one meaningful alternative scenario when the recommended pay result is sensitive to a judgment call. The purpose is not to overwhelm directors with rows of salary data; it is to permit an informed, defensible decision.
For certain public charities, the IRS Section 4958 rebuttable-presumption framework addresses independent approval, appropriate comparability evidence and contemporaneous documentation. Private foundations are subject to a different self-dealing framework, including Section 4941 compensation exceptions where applicable. Seek qualified tax/legal review; a market study does not itself establish compliance.
Use the nonprofit compensation committee checklist to assign the reviewers and maintain records, and the nonprofit compensation policy template to document future review cycles. Do not confuse governance process with the technical exercise of selecting salary peers.
What Should a Foundation Request From an Independent Consultant?
Require a role-matching log, explicit primary and secondary peer sets, survey-source and data-year inventory, stated exclusions, confidence and limitations commentary, proposed pay positioning and a short board-ready explanation. Ask the consultant to present alternatives when the data do not support a single precise estimate. Specific recommendations should be tied to the foundation's ability to implement them.
If the organization is preparing an engagement, read why organizations hire an independent compensation consultant alongside the compensation study process. A 2027 nonprofit compensation planning checklist can help convert the resulting evidence into a budget-cycle decision rather than an unused report.
Seven-Step Foundation Benchmarking Checklist
- Describe the board or HR decision the data must support.
- Confirm job content and decision authority with managers before matching.
- Segment foundation-specific, broadly transferable and highly specialized roles.
- Define preferred peer characteristics and exclusion criteria before seeing results.
- Validate survey data years, pay elements, sample coverage and usage rights.
- Test alternative peer sets when geography or sample choice changes the conclusion.
- Present evidence, uncertainty and a documented action plan to decision-makers.
After defining credible peers, the foundation can address adjacent questions of compensation strategy, pay equity assessment and executive pay governance. These deserve their own decisions rather than being buried in one benchmark number.
Related Foundation Compensation Resources
For planning a grantmaker-specific project, see JER HR Group foundation compensation consulting, nonprofit executive compensation guidance, and the compensation survey source guide. For technical research and scope decisions, review market data quality criteria and custom salary benchmarking options.
Editorial note: This US-focused guide discusses publicly available grantmaker survey information and IRS guidance. It does not reproduce licensed salary survey results, offer legal or tax advice, or guarantee any compensation or regulatory outcome.
Frequently Asked Questions About Foundation Salary Benchmarking Peers
What makes another foundation a useful salary benchmarking peer?
A useful peer provides compensation evidence for comparable work in a relevant labor market. Begin with actual job responsibilities, authority, skills and recruiting market; then consider grantmaking model, scale and geography. A nearby office or similar endowment size is not adequate evidence on its own.
Can community foundations benchmark salaries against private foundations?
Yes, when specific jobs and recruiting markets genuinely match. Community foundations often have donor-services or local partnership duties that differ from private foundation roles. An analyst should compare responsibilities and authority rather than just title, then explain which private foundation observations are direct matches and which are merely secondary evidence.
How many peer foundations are needed for a credible salary review?
No universal number makes a peer group valid. Adequacy depends on the similarity of jobs, survey reporting rules, the market being measured and the board decision. Ask for limitations and sensitivity checks rather than trusting a precise salary figure derived from an unrepresentative sample.
Is the 2026 Council on Foundations survey enough for benchmarking?
It is an important starting source for grantmaker compensation because it addresses foundation and grantmaker types, organizational scale and geography. Whether it is sufficient depends on role definitions, data coverage and pay components for the exact job. A specialized or hybrid role may require additional licensed surveys or a tailored analysis.
Can Form 990 or Form 990-PF compensation replace a salary survey?
Usually not as the only source. Public returns disclose selected reported compensation but may lag the labor market and often do not describe responsibilities well enough for reliable job matching. They can inform organizational context or cross-checks when documented, not serve as a complete market percentile for a foundation position.
Should geographic location always determine foundation salary peers?
Geography matters when the foundation hires within a local or regional market. A nationally recruited executive or investment professional may compete against employers across the country. Define the likely recruitment area for each position, account for remote work and explain any geographic adjustment before applying a market figure.
When should a foundation commission custom peer benchmarking?
Custom benchmarking is appropriate when existing survey matches, sample coverage or labor-market definitions are too weak for the decision, especially for unusual grantmaking or specialist work. Start by documenting gaps and reviewing available surveys. Commission additional research when it can materially improve the quality of the resulting recommendation.

